Connect with us


NBA and other leagues should skip the fake crowd noise and let fans hear the game

As sports without fans in the stands looks set to be the norm for at least the foreseeable future, TV broadcasts are scrambling for ways to present the games as those at home are used to seeing them. That has led to some pretty interesting proposals. One idea that has become fairly popular is to…Read More

As sports without fans in the stands looks set to be the norm for at least the foreseeable future, TV broadcasts are scrambling for ways to present the games as those at home are used to seeing them. That has led to some pretty interesting proposals.

One idea that has become fairly popular is to use simulated crowd noise to try to fill out the broadcast. This is often done by turning to video games; the NBA has proposed using sound from the popular “NBA 2K” video game in the absence of fans. In England, things are even more elaborate, as soccer’s Premier League is working with programmers from EA Sports’ “FIFA” series to create team-specific crowd noise for broadcasts. That will be an optional feature, and viewers will be able to watch a telecast without the artificial crowd noise on a separate channel. The discussions have even extended to the NFL; while we still don’t know if there will be fans at football games this fall, the notion of using artificial crowd noise has been brought up there, too.

The major sports leagues to return to play thus far, however, have gone against the grain. The KBO, Korea’s baseball league, and the Bundesliga, Germany’s top soccer league, are showing games without any artificial add-ons. The experience has been interesting. Though the language barrier in both countries prevents English-speaking fans from getting the full experience, players and coaches can be heard yelling and cheering each other on. Interactions are there for all to hear between everyone on the field.

This adds a neat dynamic that is absent from regular games. Referees are mic’d in many sports, and there are microphones to pick up the sound of the action, but in general, the crowd noise drowns out the bulk of the chatter. There’s something deeply interesting, though, about hearing players talking to each other. When they score, we can hear their excitement. When something doesn’t go their way, their frustration is there for all to hear. Interactions with opposing players or referees can be seen and scrutinized. None of this is possible with fans in the stands — or with fake crowd noise obscuring it.

To be clear, there are definitely issues that need to be addressed if no crowd noise is being used. Players may be prone to using strong language that typically goes unheard on TV broadcasts, which could pose a problem for networks and may require some sort of tape delay. At least one referee has voiced some concerns over officiating in an empty arena, where every one of his interactions with players, coaches, and fellow officials has the potential to be picked up by a TV broadcast.

These are valid concerns, and should absolutely be considered and addressed before sports are put back on U.S. television. That said, the benefits outweigh the risks. These games could function as something like a behind-the-scenes look at how the game is actually played and what everyone on the court hears and experiences in the heat of the moment. That could be good for the product. It could allow players and coaches to show some personality. It could also humanize everyone involved, particularly referees, who are typically ignored unless they do something controversial.

There should be ways to address any concerns raised by those on the field or the court about their discussions being heard by an unintended audience. In the end, though, as long as those concerns are addressed, leagues and TV broadcasters should skip the fake crowd noise and use this opportunity to give fans a more unfiltered look at their favorite sports and players. At the very least, if they do insist on crowd noise, they should take a page from the Premier League and make those broadcasts optional. It would make the long-awaited return of sports even more interesting and intriguing.

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


MLB2 years ago

The Greatest Sports Call in Broadcasting History

Kirk Gibson’s 1988 World Series home run was a baseball play that occurred in Game 1 of the 1988 World...

NFL2 years ago

Rob Gronkowski “Just Joking” About Having Bucs’ Playbook

Rob Gronkowski posted a note on social media Wednesday to make clear that he was just joking when talking about...

MLB2 years ago

MLB Proposes 3-Division 2020 Play Based on Geography

MLB is one of the games genuinely faithful to its legacy, however even they are thinking about radical changes because...

NHL2 years ago

NHL Eyes December to Start 2020-21 Season

The 2019-20 NHL season has been suspended for about a month and a half now as the world fights the...

NHL2 years ago

5 Greatest Hockey Players of All-Time

This list hasn’t changed in 20 years. I can’t envision the rundown changing at any point in the near future....

NFL2 years ago

NFL Draft Made These 3 Teams Playoff Contenders

The 2020 NFL Draft spoke to an open door for NFL groups to drastically improve their lists with the expectations...

NCAAF2 years ago

Trevor Lawrence Heavy Favorite to be #1 Pick 2021 Draft

The 2020 NFL Draft is in the books and the football world is as of now amped up for the...

MLB2 years ago

Fan Made Epic Fenway Park Map in Fortnite

The COVID-19 pandemic has forestalled avid supporters from getting a charge out of baseball for about two months. While baseball...

NBA2 years ago

Vegas: Dennis Rodman Potential Successor to Kim Jong-Un

There’s a great deal of disarray encompassing the soundness of Kim Jong-un, the 36-year-old Supreme Leader of Democratic People’s Republic...

NBA2 years ago

Blake Griffin Calls Out TMZ Coverage

Detroit Pistons star Blake Griffin was as of late an objective of TMZ, which posted a strange article about him...